Analog Fights Back: Some Things Are Worth Keeping

mixtapesI like durable wood, leather and metal that can last a lifetime. I’m no Luddite, but I also don’t dismiss the handmade and analog. I admire it for its stubborn staying power. I remember the cassette tapes I made decades ago to fit every mood I was in. A colleague back then curated one for me; he called it “Tekla’s Troopers,” and it always gave me a boost. Ironically, I’ve misplaced it.

I still have old fountain pens, leather-bound notebooks and old newspapers and magazine clippings that hold meaning, some from centuries ago. I give them their place in my modern world.

You can defend the analog while appreciating the digital, or AI, when it suits you. I just purchased a new analog radio (with Bluetooth): its wooden exterior, simple manual dial and brass buttons that click when adjusted add a satisfying visceral haptic feel and pleasant friction.

I want enough tech at my disposal to be more productive and efficient at work and at home, but not for that technology to take over my life. Don’t you miss the days when being online was a choice and not a must, and you left yourself space for much else?

 

The photos we never look at

 

I also feel unease about the deluge of digital photos that we dump into the cloud, created on the fly without a second thought. Memories will be lost, and future generations will have much less to remember us by.

The more pictures you post online or upload to the cloud, the more meaningless they become.

Compared to the few printed photos in family albums that still hold meaning decades from now, these digital snapshots live only in the moment.

Fairfield University psychologist Linda Henkel noted in 2014 in Psychological Science that photographing something reduces how well you remember it. She stresses that “to remember, we have to access and interact with the photos, rather than just amass them.”

Each year, I print out what I call our VIP photos and create a physical photo album. They are in a bookcase in our dining room, and we often look at them. They will outlast us.

I measure my writing, or other authors’ writings, and the objects that surround me by whether they can stand up against time and hold meaning beyond the immediate here and now. And I believe we create real impact only when we write for future readers, not when we’re discarded like an old shoe.

“Analog is messy and imperfect, just like the real world,” writes David Sax in The Future Is Analog (2022). “Real experiences. Visceral emotions. Meaningful relationships. The full-body roller coaster that is human existence on planet Earth. It’s the centerpiece of any future, not the sideshow, the realm of emotion and relationships, real community, human friendships and love.”

 

The right to repair

 

But living in the space between the old and the new is exhausting. For example, it’s become much harder to fix handmade goods instead of discarding them for cheaper, mass-produced alternatives.

It has become easier to buy new replacements, but that attitude is slowly shifting.

In the EU, the Right to Repair Directive passed in 2024, requiring manufacturers to repair products beyond the warranty period. In the US, over 40 states have introduced similar legislation.

The repair café movement, a community of workshops where people bring broken objects to be fixed for free, was founded in 2010 by the Repair Café Foundation in Amsterdam and has over 2,500 locations in 40 countries as of this writing (including 200 in the United States).

All these efforts link back to the original Arts and Crafts Movement, which emerged in the late nineteenth century as a response to the industrialized manufacturing of household goods. It offered a practical yet philosophical alternative, assigning handmade goods (ceramics, furniture, clothing) a new, elevated value in contrast to the mass-produced goods that were becoming dominant.

Today’s efforts by digital natives to celebrate the handmade also align with the agile software movement. It published its manifesto in 2001 and based itself on the skilled craft guilds of previous centuries, adopting qualitative, humanistic principles such as “individuals and interactions over processes and tools” as its core ideals.

 

Gen Z wants analog back

 

“WeWork Street” performance art installation by the comedic collective Improv Everywhere in November 2018

A movement in creativity, design and everyday living advocates for a different, slower, more tangible path. Some of us started fighting for quality over quantity, for permanence over speed, years ago.

If you are fluent in the analog world, you are better at creating and consuming digital content.

And more and more younger people are joining us, particularly Gen Z, the generation most immersed in digital from birth, who are now actively seeking its opposite, even pushing back against AI. The Recording Industry Association of America has reported vinyl outselling CDs for the first time since the 1980s, driven largely by younger buyers: 46.8 million EPs/LPs were sold in the U.S. in 2025, up from less than a million in 2006.

Many books have been published to preach what I’ve been practicing all along: newer isn’t necessarily better. Slow and messy can be an advantage.

“The Revenge of Analog is occurring now precisely because digital technology has become so damn good,” writes David Sax in The Revenge of Analog (2016). “To build a more human future, we need to invest in analog reality, in all its messy glory. The analog experience is the real deal. The source code. The reference point against which every secondhand, digital experience is measured. The future is analog because we are analog.”

 

What the Met was like in 1928

 

H.O. Studley Tool Chest, a 19th-century carpenter’s and piano-maker’s tool cabinet

Vinyl, paper notebooks and fountain pens are having a comeback among young and old alike. It is a longing for the tactile that a film from the 1920s captures perfectly.

I just watched a short video from The Metropolitan Museum of Art from 1928 introducing the behind-the-scenes craftsmen and women, curators and photographers, carpenters, painters and upholsterers who meticulously cared for the museum and its collection. It’s fascinating to see how much work was done by hand on site. Much of it was made possible by the WPA of the New Deal.

I felt a pang of regret about how much of this work is outsourced today to other countries, robots and automated machines. The pride artisans once took in their craft has given way to today’s throwaway culture.

 

Kafka didn’t want to be remembered

 

Franz Kafka

Creativity, analog and digital, is meant to be timeless. Even though the Czech novelist Franz Kafka (1883-1924) instructed his friend Max Brod to burn all his writings “completely and unread” after his death, his writing endured.

A recent exhibit at The Morgan Library about Kafka, which was well-received, proved this. Seeing Kafka’s original manuscripts, his scribbles, edits and annotations up close showed us a more complex and charming man, so different from the sad figure with sunken eyes who died young.

In 2019, the National Library of Israel digitized hundreds of Kafka’s drawings that had been kept under lock and key for decades, made them publicly accessible and compiled them into a book.

But Kafka wanted what many fear: to be forgotten.

Ironically, today’s content creators and influencers would agree: they want immediate, short, scannable content that is forgotten once it hits peak virality.

 

Why friction matters

 

Slow, physical writing counteracts the disposability of viral content and outlasts it.

Handwriting during Kafka’s time (and today) is slow writing made physical. It is old-fashioned labor, and maybe that’s why it endures and engages our brains more than typing ever can.

It’s the tactile, haptic resistance, texture and crinkling of the page; the time it takes to formulate the right word, the inability to delete without a trace that creates a different relationship to language than the frictionless, revisable, instant world of the keyboard.

Friction sparks creativity.

Thoughts written on paper stem information overload because the reader controls intake in a linear, serendipitous way, with a sense of surprise.

Working digitally prevents friction by automating, smoothing and removing resistance. But digital tools are not always time-savers: According to a 2026 Workday report, nearly 40% of AI-generated time savings are lost to fixing low-quality output.

Tediousness and getting your hands dirty should be part of ideation and discovery. Creativity, in writing, designing, or art, needs friction and the feeling of being in charge, even if it takes more time.

Working analog means allowing painstaking friction into your process.

Kafka’s work endured because it was analog and physical and because a friend held Kafka’s manuscripts in his hands, maybe sniffed the ink he used, and refused to obey the writer’s wishes.

A similar deliberate analog or thoughtful digital approach can help you slow down and create something that outlasts you.

 

Letters that outlasted a lifetime

 

A letter collage my parents sent to me, as we lived on different continents

I only wrote by hand when I corresponded with my parents. We were enthusiastic letter writers because we lived on different continents for decades. I have countless letters from them with their original drawings and collages (both were artists), cataloged nowhere. Newspaper cuttings, many, many art postcards and one-of-a-kind pieces. Exhibition invitations that became letters.

Letters folded, quartered, in scraps, glued and decorated. Letters on cardboard and letters on rice paper. Some faded faxes with scribbled notes, but no emails.

When the container with their belongings arrived in New York after my parents passed away an ocean away, I also received the letters I wrote to them, now united with their letters to me.

A lasting collection of decades of shared life events and memories. Words, analog artifacts, designs and photographs created with the thought that they’ll be accessible and needed in the future.

“We assume that anyone who rejects a new tool in favor of an older one is guilty of nostalgia, of making choices sentimentally rather than rationally,” writes Nicholas Carr in The Glass Cage (2014). “But the real sentimental fallacy is the assumption that the new thing is always better suited to our purposes and intentions than the old thing.”

The nod to the past, often led by people who never knew the analog world in the first place, isn’t a nostalgic rejection of modernity and efficiency. It is an emotional anchor, a commitment to quality, timelessness and what it means to be human. Kafka would have agreed.

 

 

More on the Topic from the Blog:

Head to Heart to Hand: How the Pen Changes Your Mind 

Books Are Not Dead. Your Attention? Maybe

Slow Writing vs. Speed Writing

 

 

 

Newsletter Signup   

 

I’ll be in your inbox every other Wednesday with actionable content + design tips and tricks, checklists and tools that you can apply immediately. I’ll share links to relevant blog posts (mine and curated recommended must-reads) and other engaging content to help you amplify your message and find the right site design. 

 

 

Copyright © Tekla Szymanski Content + Design LLC. All rights reserved. Please share/quote with attribution.
About the author

Polyglot Localization Expert & Editor | German · US English | Sentient Cultural Radar & Human-in-the-Loop | NYC • Berlin | Founder of Content+Design™ LLC. Creating stories that resonate contextually and authentically across borders.


Certifications

NYS-certified woman-owned business

AI Master

Google-certified Project Management

Yoast SEO for WordPress

Yoast Structured Data

Yoast Keyword Research

Memberships

Women in AI

 

Online News Association

 

NYWICI Award-winning member

 

EFA Member

 

Society of Professional JournalistsPen America

Copyright

Creative Commons License

Licensed under Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial 4.0 International License.
Please share and attribute. Don’t copy. Thank you.